Remember to enter the Massive
Giveaway, which still has plenty of time to run.
This week we read up to the end of
Chapter 57.
1. What do
you think of Dalinar's latest vision concerning the Radiants? Can you make
sense of them? Do you think Jasnah will prove or disprove Dalinar's visions?
And what did you think of Dalinar and Navani's almost moment? ;)
I really want to know why the Radiants laid down
their shards and walked away from the conflict. Was this due to the nine
Heralds breaking the Oathpact or something else? Also, I want to know where
they went and if their powers faded afterwards, like the glow fading from their
shards. Plus, what happened to all those shards: Dalinar realizes that the ones
he sees are far more than all the ones known in modern Rosahr. As always, this
was an awesome scene, but it left me with many more questions than it answered.
I am certain that Jasnah will prove that the
visions are real. They seem far too detailed and pointed to be delusions or
random hallucinations. They are obviously trying to communicate important
pieces of history to Dalinar for some reason that is not entirely clear at the
moment. However, it seems that a Desolation is coming, perhaps the True
Desolation that the Radiant in the vision mentioned.
To be quite honest, I could do without the hints at
romance that we are seeing between these two. Dalinar has more than enough to
deal with and does not need the added complication of all this emotional
turmoil as well. I hope that Navani realizes this pretty soon and stops trying
to push his buttons.
2. Dalinar
proposes a military alliance with Sadeas. Given what we've read of their
relationship and of Sadeas' character, did Dalinar make the right move? How
long do you think this alliance will last? Has Dalinar finally gotten Sadeas on
his side by using Sadeas' interests (gemhearts, the Shardblade, etc.) as
incentive or does Dalinar have something else up his sleeve?
I still find it very difficult to trust Sadeas, so
I have to believe that Dalinar’s need to trust him has a reason that we cannot
see yet. Perhaps it will lead to some important event that is necessary for
Dalinar to convince the Highprinces to fight together. However, it makes me
uneasy, and Sadeas’ apparent good will over the saddle strap just makes me more
suspicious. I am pretty sure that Sadeas will betray Dalinar without a second
thought and I was rather hoping that he had been finished off by the Parshendi.
3. This is
the first time we've read in detail what it's like to be a Shardbearer fighting
with Shardblades in battle through Dalinar. What did you think of it?
As I said last week, it reminded me a great deal of
Sauron smashing the ranks of elves and humans and sending them flying with his
mace. It also reminded me a little of reading Starship Troopers by Robert A.
Heinlein, which includes characters fighting in powered suits.
The power that Dalinar displays makes me wonder
what the hundreds of Knights Radiant were up against. If they were needed in
such numbers, the voidbringers must be truly terrible.
4. We get a
big reveal about what's happening with Kaladin this week regarding the
Stormlight as well as a revelation regarding Syl's nature. What did you think
of it? Given what we know now, what else do you think he is capable of?
This really just confirmed what we have all been
piecing together over the last few weeks. It particularly confirmed our
suggestions that he had similar abilities to those that we see Szeth use. We
definitely saw him ‘lashing’ objects, such as the medical pack and the stone,
although he does it in an unconscious way.
Again, I think we had all pretty much decided that
Syl was not a normal windspren, if she was one. It now seems that her role in
life is to bind to a warrior, attracted by and enhancing his ability to
manipulate Stormlight. I suspect that this binding is a fundamental step in the
process of becoming a Knight Radiant. Of course, this makes me wonder why Szeth
does not have his own spren. We know that Syl is unhappy about the need to
kill, so perhaps Szeth’s work as an assassin has made him repellent to her type
of spren.
I see no reason why Kal cannot become as skilled as
Szeth, perhaps even more so because he has his bond with Syl.
5. Kaladin
initially blames his curse as the reason why people around him keep dying. Is
there some truth to his claims, that this binding ability has some correlation
with the casualty count around him, or is Kaladin simply grieving over recent
losses? If the former, do you think this might have any connection to what the
Radiants are and whatever happened to them?
No, Kal’s ability has not caused the men around him
to die at a higher rate. In fact, they seem to survive much longer because of
his skill and ability. However, he has a very skewed view of what has happened
because he has survived far more fighting than he should have. A normal soldier
would have seen much less death because he would not have Kal’s ability to
survive for so long in such dangerous situations.
I think the real problem is that Kal holds himself
responsible for everybody else. He has a rather adolescent and arrogant
worldview that gives him the duty of caring for everyone. Obviously, this is an
impossible task and so he constantly fails to keep them all alive and then he
sulks and moans about the unfairness of the world. I know that this sounds
rather harsh, but he has not yet learnt the wisdom to allow others to take
responsibility for themselves. I think he is almost about to make that break
through, and it will give him a great deal of peace to know that he can only do
so much.
6. Wit/Hoid
is turning out to be more than just the life of the party and a thorn on the
sides of the other highprinces. As we've seen, he's not very playful with
Dalinar and is quite sober, even ominous, with Kaladin. What did you think of
his conversations with Dalinar and with Kaladin? What do you think he's up to?
How does he factor in with everything else that's going on at the moment (or
what's to come)?
Hoid is a character who can hop between the worlds
in the Cosmere, although we do not know how if does this. From some of the
things he said to Kal, I got the impression that he had travelled to Roshar in
pursuit of Odium, which suggests that he is either another of the Sixteen
Shards or a similarly powerful being. He is most certainly not just a wandering
bard.
I am fairly sure that he is linked to the visions
that both men are receiving. Although I am not sure how he could be involved,
it is certainly far too much of a coincidence that he speaks to these two so
differently from everyone else. It seemed as if he was waiting to speak to Kal
before leaving, which also adds to the impression that he knows something of
their fates / destinies.
Other Notes
I was sadly disappointed to find out that my guess
was correct: Amaram was a total dirtbag and stole the shards that Kal had won.
In some way, I wish he had simply been honest about it rather than making up a
pathetic excuse about it being for the good of the army. What a sad specimen of
a man! Leaving Kal alive was such a generous action . . . grumble, grumble,
grumble . . . grrrr! :(
I loved the interlude with Baxil, but it opened up
so many more questions! Why was their mistress so determined to break into
houses and smash up works of art? We also got a little more of an idea about
the Old Magic and how it works. I was a little surprised to read that the
Nightwatcher could be a spren. This suggests that some spren have quite a
significant magical ability all of their own. It also seems to answer the
questions about what happened to Dalinar’s memories of his wife: although we do
not know if that was the curse or the boon.
So, flamespren become fixed once you measure them? Just
when I thought that this world could not get any more cool! The fact that they
would only do it if you wrote the number down was even more astounding. This
suggests that words, or writing, have power in this world so perhaps the
burning of prayer glyphs is not so pointless after all.
Poor Szeth! His mind is being totally warped by all
this killing, especially when he has to take so many innocent lives. I am
beginning to wonder why he does not allow himself to be killed by one of his
intended victims so that he can end his suffering.
What is wrong with Renarin: what are his fits of
weakness?
I loved the idea of the watch kept over the
latrines to make sure that the bridgecrews were not swallowing shards during
chasm duty. It also made me feel very sorry for the poor Parshmen who had to
check afterwards . . . :(
I am intrigued to learn what Kal has in mind for
Shen. It was certainly a shock to see the little Parshman become so agitated
about the Parshendi corpses. There is so much more to him than meets the eye.
I was very pleased to see Dalinar finally taking
some notice of the Parshedi warriors and asking himself about them and their society.
There are so many strange things going on with this war: someone needs to start
finding answers!
I'm not sure I entirely want to trust Sadeas yet either. I hope we get more of Baxil as well. I really want to know who their mistress is. And Renarin is an interesting aside as well. I wonder if he has anything to do with the boon and curse Dalinar once received?
ReplyDeleteI love (and hate) the interludes because they provide so much depth to the world and yet they make me frustrated because they give such brief glimpses of things that I want to know all about ! Grr!
DeleteI wonder if he used to be much worse and Dalinar asked for him to be healed. The only argument I can make against that idea is that Adolin does not seem to know anything about it, which seems strange.
I was really surprised that Sadeas was using the investigation in a way to stop suspicion falling on Dalinar. It did make me feel a little guilty about all the harsh things/thoughts I've been having and saying about him - but, he is pretty mean to the bridgecrew (although I suppose this is purely battle tactics.
ReplyDeleteI loved the reveal about Syl - she's such a great character. I really enjoy all her little bits.
I sincerely hope that Kaladin starts to be a bit more reasonable about his ability to keep EVERYONE alive. He's already helped the bridgecrew a lot more than he seems to realise or give himself credit for. After all - there's a war going on and people do die in these circumstances.
Lynn :D
I still can't make myself trust Sadeas . . . even now!
DeleteIt is laudable that Kal wants to keep everyone alive, but it has a very juvenile quality to it: it is as if he can't accept the world as it truly is.
That's exactly how I feel about Kaladin, too. His insistence on being responsible for everyone around him not only harms his own mental health, but is also extremely self-centered. I don't think he's consciously realized it (and I don't think he is intentionally being arrogant), but his worldview relies on the assumption that only *his* actions and decisions can make a difference. It seems like he's on the verge of truly understanding that other people can take responsibility, too.
ReplyDeleteAbout Renarin, I could be totally off-base, but I assumed he had epilepsy (maybe only invisible seizures though, hence the 'fits of weakness').
I am also really curious to see what becomes of Shen. It seems like people mostly treat Parshmen like objects, and I hope we get to understand more of what's going on inside his head.
Yep, that's why I feel like he is showing adolescent thought patterns: he needs to mature a bit and realize that he can't control everything. I agree: I don't blame him or see this as him being a bad person, just very young. I keep forgetting that he's only 19 or so, which might explain his rather immature attitude.
DeleteYeah, I immediately thought epilepsy as well, but who knows with Mr Sanderson? :D
I thought his reaction to the handling of the dead was very telling: it was as if he suddenly woke up from a sleep of indifference.