My
Rating: 1.0 / 5.0
Amazon Rating: 4.50 / 5.00
Goodreads Rating: 4.10 / 5.00
Morgaine, half-sister to the
legendary King, is the central character in this epic retelling of the
Arthurian legend.
I have to admit that I approached
this title with huge expectations. It is repeatedly given rave reviews for its
feminist take on the Arthurian legend and is often held aloft as a classic of
the Fantasy genre. It was also highly recommended during the Women in SF&F
month at Fantasy Cafe. Add into
the mix the fact that I am quite fond of the Arthurian legend and its
retellings in literature, and I find it very difficult to truly express how
massively disappointed I was by this title.
I once heard someone talking about
watching Wagner’s operas, saying that you feel as if you have been listening
for three hours and then look at your watch to find that only ten minutes have
passed. I felt something very similar when I began to read the somewhat
daunting brick that I borrowed from the library. I read and read and read and
looked up to find that I was still on page eleven. After several more hours of
self-imposed torture I had staggered to approximately page sixty, at which
point the remaining eight hundred pages looked like a cruel and unnecessary
punishment to inflict upon myself and I gave up. Sometimes life is just too
short to spend so much time being miserable!
So, what was my problem: why could I
not force myself to read this much beloved tome? It certainly was not the
length of the book. I am currently half way through the fourteen volume
monstrosity that is Robert Jordan’s Wheel of Time series and am happily hurting
my wrists wrestling with the one thousand page door stop that is The Way of
Kings by Brandon Sanderson. No, I am quite happy reading long books: in fact
many of my favorites are mammoth tomes that almost knock me out if I let them
fall onto my face whilst reading in bed.
I have to admit that I was severely
disturbed by a plot point early on, where there is reference to Christianity
arriving in England before the Romans. Even if one discounts the invasions led
by Julius Caesar in 55-54 BCE, there is little chance that Christianity could
have arrived before the Emperor Claudius began his conquest in 43 CE. There was
also mention of the raiding Scots, even though that term was not applied to any
of the tribes living in what is now Scotland: the Scotti tribe were actually
from modern day Ireland. These are points of historical knowledge that would
probably not bother other readers, but they made me lose a great deal of
confidence in the author and her research.
However, my biggest problems with
this title was the writing and the horribly weak female characters that I encountered.
I have read plenty of dense historical texts and convoluted biochemical
pathways laid out as a wall of text, and I am afraid to say that this book was
on a similar level for its ease of reading and absorption. I am a slow reader,
and yet even I am not familiar with taking over five minutes to read a single
page. This slowness was not because I had to reread sections to understand
them, but because the language was so dense and detail-laden that it simply
took me that long to physically move my brain through the information that it
was trying to absorb. If you think Tolkien that is dry to read, then I heartily
recommend that you avoid this title all together. The prose is so convoluted
and over-worked that reading it is almost like wading through treacle. Not only
is the writing difficult to work through, but it is also stuffed full of
pointless, boring details. I do not really care what exactly Igraine is wearing
every time we see her, or what everyone else is wearing or what they eat, etc.,
etc. We all know that life was harsh and the women spent most of their time
raising children or running their household, so I really do not need to know
what shade of brown she is wearing each day.
Considering that this is supposed to
be a feminist tract, I had rather hoped to see a great deal less of the boring day
to day tedium and explore a little more of how these women were exerting their
power over their own worlds. Only we do not get a sense of that at all. Igraine
is thoroughly down trodden and really rather wet. She was married off to her
husband because that was what the Goddess wanted. I know that she was only
sixteen or so when she married him, but that was not all that young at that
time. The Empress Livia was already pregnant with her second child when she met
and wooed the man who would become the Emperor Augustus. She divorced her
existing husband and married Augustus soon afterwards at the grand old age of
twenty. We forget that, in this period of history, a woman of fourteen was just
that: a woman.
I got no sense that Igraine was
anything other than a teenager: petulant and yet ineffective. She openly states
that she refuses to obey the next demand from the goddess but is swept along by
fate, agreeing to go to Londinium and strangely attracted to the man that she
is supposed to seduce in order to conceive Arthur. No doubt she falls under his
spell and gives in, otherwise the story would have been much shorter, but I did
not feel as if she truly felt compelled by the wises of the Goddess or that she
was actively trying to avoid the fate laid out for her. This seemed like a real
misstep, because Igraine commits adultery to conceive Arthur and I would have
liked to see some purposeful decision-making from her one way or the other.
In short, this was a very
disappointing experience for me and has led me to remove this title from my
list of books for the Worlds Without End 2014 Women of
Genre Fiction Reading Challenge. I have replaced it with The Shore of Women
by Pamela Sargent, in the hope that will I have more fun with that title.
For those of you looking for
alternative versions of the Arthurian legend that are well worth a read, I can
suggest the excellent Arthur Books by
Bernard Cornwell as well as The Arthurian Saga
by Mary Stewart.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Please let me know what you think, because comments make me happy!
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.