You can head over to Musings
on Fantasia to see what everyone else thinks.
This week we read up to the end of
Chapter 65.
1. Andolin
has a change of heart, not only about his father, but about how he views the
war. How do you think this will affect the story going forward?
I feel as though Adolin has shown quite a lot of
maturity in his thinking. Rather than simply throwing his rattle out of the
pram and behaving like a spoilt child, he has spent considerable time examining
the situation and has come to some the conclusion that his father is probably
right. I had thought that his Calling as a Duelist could have been due to a
shallow understanding of warfare, but I see that is not true. Obviously he is
being influenced by his father, but Renarin seems like a level-headed chap and
even Adolin’s friends are not as fixated on excitement as I might have feared.
I am glad that House Kholin will present a united
front to the other Highprinces and that we will not be subjected to the
depressing father-son conflict that seemed to be brewing. Somehow I think that
Dalinar will have enough trouble with the other Houses.
2. Elhokar
reveals that he sees figures with symbol heads, which sound suspiciously like
the ones Shallan keeps drawing. What do you make of this?
That was my first thought: these figures sound an
awful lot like the ones that Shallan has been drawing. It is interesting to
note that he only sees them in reflections, and not directly. For some reason
these figures are not normally seen, so what makes these two people special? Of
course, seeing figures that are invisible to everyone else would make anyone
paranoid, so I wonder if these are responsible for all the people that he
thinks are trying to assassinate him.
I actually find it heartening that Elhokar might
have some interesting talent that we had not previously suspected. So far he
has been fairly ineffectual and weak, but the rest of his family is rather extraordinary,
and we know that Jasnah can Soulcast without a fabrial . . .
3. What do
you make of Dalivar's most recent vision? Was the king he talked to really
Nohadon, author of The Way of Kings? If so, what do you think the timeline is?
What happened before and after what Dalinar saw? Were the strange, rock-like
corpses really Voidbringers?
Each of these visions is so tantalizing and yet so
frustrating! It would seem that the name Desolation is very fitting for an
event that can kill almost all of the people as we see here. I sincerely hope
that this is the very end of the Desolation, as I cannot begin to imagine how
the people will continue to fight in their weakened state. However, I am
intrigued by Nohadon’s comments about mankind being weakened by each Desolation
rather than strengthened and his frustration about the infighting that
preoccupies his men. This seems like a very good reason to write the Way of
Kings once he has them time, and also mirrors Dalinar’s frustration in the
present. It makes me even more curious to learn why the Radiants stopped
fighting.
It would seem that this vision came before the last
one, when Dalinar saw the Knights Radiant laying down their shards. However,
that is about as close to a guess as I can come. As for the corpses being
Voidbringers: it is entirely possible, as they certainly seem unlike anything
else we have heard described so far.
4. Dalivar
and Navani finally share a passionate kiss, and then start conducting a covert
romance. What are your impressions of the relationship? Has your opinion of
Navani changed at all?
I find the Romance element here more distracting
than anything else, but it does seem to be progressing in a sensible fashion,
so I can forgive Mr Sanderson for including it! :D
One thing that I do like about their relationship
is all the back-story. There is no doubt in my mind that these two would have
married if Dalinar had not stepped back to allow Gavilar to claim Navani. This
has led Dalinar to cut her out of his heart in order to live with that choice
and still continue to interact with her. For Navani, I can see how she might
have been very disappointed that Dalinar did not choose to fight for her: as
she says, he appeared somewhat fickle to her. The weight of their previous
lives is very obvious in everything that has happened between them so far and
yet they seem destined to be together. Can they just get married so that we can
ignore all this Romance twaddle from now on?
I think that I have come to understand Navani a lot
more as we have learnt more of her past with Dalinar. There has to be some
awkwardness in trying to resume a relationship that has been so strained for so
many years. I think that her initial approaches were somewhat misguided, driven
by her own feelings of loneliness and the hope that he would simply revert to
his boyhood character if she showed some interest. She quickly learnt that he
could not do that, but modified her behavior to win his approval, which shows
not only that she has very deep feelings for him, but also that she is a
thoughtful and emotionally controlled character.
5. Kaladin's
decoy plan works almost miraculously well. How do you see this affecting the
story going forward, and in what way? Address the issue both for Kaladin and
his men, and for the war at large.
We have seen Kal and Bridge Four surviving more
runs than anyone would think possible, especially now that they all have the
armor. However, this was counteracted pretty quickly by them being placed on
permanent run duty, so I am not sure that they will stick around for long.
Whilst it seems like a very good way to protect the bridgemen, it drastically
affects the Parshendi battle strategy. If this proves to be beneficial to the
overall battle plan then I cannot see any good reason to stop using the armor.
However, anything that sensible seems beyond the Alethi Highprinces . . .
6. So Moash
wants to kill someone out of vengeance. Any guesses who or why?
I do not think that he has mentioned anyone
specifically. I would imagine that it could be the person responsible for
selling him into slavery, but I could be mistaken. Whoever it is must be
outside the Warcamps, because it is only now that he has some chance of leaving
that he has decided to exact his revenge.
7. Why do
you think Sadeas abandoned Dalivar as he did? Was this done intentionally? Was
it planned in advance? What are your thoughts?
I knew that Sadeas was Evil! :(
This was most certainly planned, because Sadeas
really pushed Dalinar to leave all his own bridges in camp and take all his
force with him. This allows Sadeas to destroy the entire force in one easy move
by leaving them to the Parshendi and withdrawing his bridges. By taking all his
forces, Dalinar has left himself with no forces to mount a rescue mission.
Although it seems that all is lost, I believe that
we have now reached the critical moment that we have all been waiting for: Kal
is going to save Dalinar by taking his bridge back to the Tower plateau. No
doubt Sadeas will be a touch upset about this, but we will finally see the two
Heroes joining forces.
Stick that in your pipe and smoke it, Sadeas! :P
Other Notes
In Dalinar’s vision it is clear that men can read
and write! Shock, horror! I still want to know where this silly idea came from,
but at least we know that it is fairly recent.
Poor Shen: how is he going to cope with everyone
wearing bits of dead Parshendi?
Just when you think you have something worked out,
Mr Sanderson smacks you in the face: what is Dalinar is correct that the
Parshendi are part of the people that he is supposed to unite?
That's what I hope, too--that Kaladin will save Dalinar somehow. Yea! I always laugh when they are scandalized about men reading and writing too. I think this is very tongue-in-cheek on Sanderson's part because he's a male who makes his living by reading and writing. And of course it turns traditional gender roles regarding education on their heads. :D
ReplyDelete