If you haven't read the book, or the whole series,
why not join in and read along with the rest of us? This week the links to the
other posts can be found at Dab
of Darkness.
This week we read through to the end of Chapter 6.
1. Rand
seems to have taken Lan's advice and is avoiding Aviendha at all costs. How
will this turn out for them? Who do you think he had in mind when he asked Mat
about being in love?
I think Rand and Aviendha are destined to be
together, so any attempts they make to avoid this outcome will be pointless. At
the moment it will probably make them both feel a little more in control of
their lives, but it will have no lasting effect on their relationship. After
all, Lan is not exactly an expert on the female animal himself, not when it
comes to romantic relationships.
He could easily have been thinking of all three of
his women, but it seems most likely that he would be most concerned about
Aviendha given her proximity and their one night of sexytimes. That episode
with Mat was more like a stream of consciousness, so I will draw a veil over
the fact that Mat is probably as useful for relationship advice as Lan! :D
2. A bunch
of men waiting to go mad, what could possibly go wrong?! What lies in the
future for these fellows? Is Rand right in trusting Taim with this?
I was almost surprised to find that any men had
volunteered to join his merry band, although it would be interesting to know
how many of them were not really interested in being able to channel and just
wanted to be part of something famous. It would seem that few of the men will
be able to channel, naturally or taught, so most of them will be sent back to
their normal lives. This might be pretty bad for them as they obviously left
those lives for a good reason. Perhaps the no-hopers will be kept on to labor
on the farm or practice various trades.
I think we were all fairly unsure about Taim and
his trustworthiness. However, Rand is not walking into this blindly, so if Taim
does turn against him it will not be much of a surprise. I think Rand’s
approach is understandable and pragmatic: he will use Taim for as long as he
can because he needs the help. Who knows, perhaps Rand’s apparent trust will
earn loyalty from Taim where indifference might not.
3. Rand's
forces just won't cooperate. Do you expect more rebellions? Is Rand making the
right choice in leaving this one to fester?
I am not sure that open rebellion will be much of a
recurring theme, especially once most people know that the Forsaken are out and
about. Also, I suspect that turning one group of rebels into a smoking mark on
the floor will do wonders for improved loyalty. I would also question just who
is rebelling. I suspect that most ordinary soldiers will switch to Rand’s side
once he throws a few lightning bolts about: it is their noble leaders who are
the true rebels.
Although I can understand the desire to squash this
rebellion at once, I think that Rand is doing the most practical thing and
resisting the temptation to waste resources chasing them around in the back
woods. I am quite sure that he has consulted with Bashere and Mat about this
and is not simply acting alone. These three have some sort of cunning plan set
up to destroy Sammael and the rebels pose no direct threat to anything important
so they can be ignored at the moment. Perhaps he can just leave them to slowly
starve to death whilst they bicker amongst themselves.
4. It seems
like the theme of chapter 4 is humor. Who did you find funniest? What's your
best joke?
I thought Rand’s joke was funny, mainly because we
were not given a proper description of any of the Aiel ones. I fail to see how
someone stabbing their wife can be hilarious, but I would have liked to have
heard the whole thing so that I could make a judgment.
I am more likely to tell funny stories than quick
jokes, so I am afraid that I do not have a favorite joke.
5. Did Mat
just… become an adoptive father? Mat doesn't strike me as the fatherly type.
How do you think this will work for him (and his officers, and of course
Olver)?
Perhaps adoptive uncle would be a better
description, as I doubt that he will be a major force for discipline in the
poor kid’s life. I thought that this was a surprise, but, then again, we know
that Mat is a true softy at heart, so it was probably only a matter of time
before he adopted a lost child or abused puppy. He will try to appear all
uncaring and macho, but Olver will be well cared for now.
I think that the rest of the Band will totally love
this move. They already worship Mat, with his amazing luck and astounding
military tactics, so to see him adopting strays will make him even more
admirable in their eyes. I predict that Olver will be adopted by the whole
group and taken to be their unofficial mascot.
6. It's time
to discuss forsaken intrigue yet again. Could you decipher anything from that
chat between Graendal and Sammael? Does anyone else feel like Sammael has made
a big mistake somewhere?
Sammael is yet another character who is so
convinced of his own rightness that he is blind to anything else. I am fairly
certain that Graendal outmaneuvered him, although there were so many feints and
bluffs within bluffs that I was getting a little confused. However, having been
inside Sammael’s head during the conversation, I do believe that she is correct
in her assessment of the man and that he has underestimated her. I suspect that
she will be one of the last Forsaken to be defeated because she has such a
great understanding of the human mind and so can manipulate people with ease.
I was shocked and intrigued by the appearance of
the two people from Shara. We know that Graendal herself is based in Arad
Doman, but this shows that she, at least, has been to Shara and is actively
involved with the people there. I want to know more about this society,
especially because it seems to have a very sensible approach to its channelers,
with an intensive breeding program in place. This suggests that they will be plentiful
and possibly more powerful than those in Randland where the Aes Sedai have
effectively been pushing the ability into extinction.
7. Just how
scary is Semirhage now, and what could Shaidar Haran possibly want with this
poor Aes Sedai (who, I believe, we have never seen before)?
I thought that the descriptions of Semirhage last
week were chilling, but we now know that she is a totally evil psychopath. Someone
needs to kill her very soon.
I assume that the Aes Sedai has some vital
information about the Salidar Aes Sedai. We now know that Mesaana is working
within the White Tower, so I assume that she is providing all the intelligence
that he needs from there. I can understand how it would be difficult to get a
spy into Salidar, where all the Sisters are watching one another and being
cautious, though this does seem rather extreme. The fact that we have not heard
of her before suggests that she is nobody important, but that would make her a
perfect target if you wanted only general information about the place and how
it is set up. She would have passwords and such like, but nobody would be too
suspicious if she went missing.
You make a good point about Mat being more uncle-y than fatherly. That's definitely true. Again you're making good guesses about Graendal and Semirhage. You see things very clearly.
ReplyDeleteI am pretty sure that Mat is the type to buy the young lad a prostitute for his 14th birthday or something similar, which seems more uncle than father behavior to me.
DeleteI am pretty sure that I am getting much more out of this read through because I am forced to slow down and pay attention - that's my excuse and I'm sticking to it! :D
I keep chuckling to myself over the men thinking they are stronger, better off with their women. They also worry about hurting them if they are near - and that is silly too. After all, they are hurting them by keeping them at arm's length, but they just don't have to see it. Makes entertaining reading tho - or perhaps I am just a sadist to take such entertainment ;).
ReplyDeleteIf Mat adopts too many lost children, he might end up with a child army - which would be disturbing in many regards, and a true headache for Mat. He is a softy, and you are right - it was only a matter of time before he adopted some lost, abused something or other.
It seems that there is all sorts of societies with Channelers - and now the Shara. The aes sedai keep looking more and more arrogant as they thought they had all this power....and really, they are just 1 of many.
I do appreciate that the men and women are made to think differently and that the girls are not just blokes with boobs, as happens in some fiction, but I wish they had a little more faith in their opposites.
DeleteAt least the Shara have a sensible system for dealing with the male channelers. I know that they get bumped off as soon as they start showing any symptoms of madness, but at least they get plenty of sexytimes first! Whilst I can't really condone treating them as sex slaves, I can applaud insisting that their genes are not wasted. That sounds a little like I espouse eugenics, but I'm not a Nazi, honestly, just looking at the advantages of not simply killing off so many people who can channel and then wondering why the ability is dying out . . . You are so right - every book adds more evidence for the utter stupidity of the Aes Sedai in general.